Questions raised on compliance with NMC guidelines
BJP-NC confrontation intensifies over controversy
Shivang Satya Gupta
JAMMU: Amid growing public outcry and deepening political confrontation, Lieutenant Governor Manoj Sinha is expected to take decisive and curative action in the coming days as the MBBS seat allocation controversy at Shri Mata Vaishno Devi (SMVD) Medical College in Katra which snowballs into one of Jammu and Kashmir’s biggest academic and governance debates of the year.
The Lt Governor administration is likely to consider the interests of all the stakeholders including students, parents, political parties, and the Shri Mata Vaishno Devi Shrine Board (SHMDSB) before initiating corrective steps.
The latest row erupted after objections were raised by various social, religious and political groups and the Sangharsh Samiti (amalgam of various organisations) regarding the selection list for 50 MBBS seats under the management quota. The controversy quickly gained momentum, with sharp political reactions emerging from both Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and National Conference (NC) over alleged irregularities and charges of politicising the issue.
Public concern heightened after a widely circulated selection list indicated that the highest-scoring candidate in SMVD Medical College under the payment quota secured 511 marks, while the last admitted candidate had 489 marks out of 720 in NEET examination, much lower than marks secured by many students unable to afford management quota fees. Critics questioned whether the National Medical Commission (NMC) mandate, which required 50 percent seats to be offered at government-rate parity in private medical colleges, had been ignored.
Aggrieved parents and students, speaking to media, said the central worry is whether SMVD Medical College adhered to the NMC rules and guidelines or bypassed them during the current and its maiden admission cycle.
Meanwhile, the experts pointed to regulations requiring every private college to fix half of its management-quota seats at government fee levels. Allegations of non-compliance have not yet been independently verified but have triggered widespread demands for transparency.
Moreover, the Sangharsh Samiti, a key driver of the agitation, argued that the issue concerns faith, merit and fairness, and not politics. The organisation is pressing for clarity on whether merit was diluted for certain candidates and whether institutions linked to a major religious shrine should follow a more transparent admission and fee structure in line with their charitable mandate.
The Samiti has also demanded a review of the revenue model, ownership, and governance processes of SMVD Medical College, highlighting long-standing questions about the transfer of assets between the Shrine Board, SMVD University, and the Charitable Society—issues that have resurfaced amid the current uproar.
Political tensions escalated further after NC leaders, including CM Omar Abdullah and MLA Tanvir Sadiq, raised the issue of admission on merit basis and opposed the demand of certain quarters. On the other hand, BJP leaders retaliated, accusing NC of injecting communal tones into what they described as a matter of student welfare and administrative propriety. Senior BJP representatives insisted the party’s stance focuses solely on merit protection, financial accountability, and rectification of any confirmed lapses.
NC leaders countered by accusing the administration of creating confusion over the governance structure of SMVD University, questioning whether it operates as an autonomous entity or under state control. They emphasised that opposition parties have a democratic duty to seek transparency in matters involving public interest.
The controversy has revived older questions regarding the complex administrative framework governing SMVD University and its medical college. Overlapping authorities involving the Shrine Board, the University, and the charitable society have caused confusion since the late 1990s, analysts said, possibly contributing to the current situation. Key concerns include whether institutional titles were transferred properly, whether the right authority vetted admissions, and whether earlier governments failed to correct governance inconsistencies.
The spotlight has now shifted to Lieutenant Governor Manoj Sinha, who heads the Shrine Board. Several groups have urged him to order a full-fledged inquiry, asserting that only an LG-monitored probe can address two decades of accumulated administrative ambiguities. They pointed to the LG’s recent strong actions such as dismissal of employees with alleged terror links and anti-corruption initiatives as indicators that he would take firm steps if irregularities are confirmed.
Pertinently, the students remain the most affected lot, particularly those who scored higher but could not afford management quota fees. Many argued that reserving half the seats at government rates, as required by NMC guidelines would have increased their chances of admission significantly. They have appealed for a review of the current academic year’s admissions before classes progress too far.
Although the administration has not issued a formal statement, initial assessments are reportedly underway. Legal action may follow, with several students considering petitions before the High Court over merit considerations, seat-sharing ratios, and compliance with national norms.
For now, the political temperatures remain high as the public demands clarity on whether rules were violated and who should be held responsible. In the days ahead, much will depend on whether the Lieutenant Governor initiates administrative corrections or whether the dispute expands into a prolonged legal and political confrontation in Jammu and Kashmir.
