Close Menu
  • Home
  • Latest Stories
  • Inking The Truth
  • Jammu & Kashmir
  • Ladakh
  • Entertainment
  • National
  • International
What's Hot

PM Modi departs from Philippines after concluding two-day visit

Yasha Mudgal reviews PACS computerisation, CAPEX expenditure; stresses timely execution

JK Migrant Deputation, Several other delegations call on Sagar

Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Wednesday, November 18
  • About
  • Contact us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Privacy Policy
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
The Earth News
E-Paper Edition
  • Home
  • Latest Stories

    PM Modi departs from Philippines after concluding two-day visit

    November 17, 2026

    Yasha Mudgal reviews PACS computerisation, CAPEX expenditure; stresses timely execution

    November 17, 2026

    JK Migrant Deputation, Several other delegations call on Sagar

    November 17, 2026

    CM Suvendu warns against conspiracies against India, says govt will not tolerate violence, lawlessness

    November 17, 2026

    MLA Mankotia calls upon Union Home Minister Amit Shah in New Delhi

    November 17, 2026
  • Inking The Truth

    Ladakh’s Polls 2026: Let facts guide the calendar

    November 11, 2026

    Karan Singh and historical ‘stakes’ of the Gor meeting

    November 9, 2026

    More Schemes, Where Are Results?

    October 17, 2026

    J&K before 2019 to be made JLK

    October 14, 2026

    Democracy on Banner, Politics on the Agenda

    October 12, 2026
  • Jammu & Kashmir

    Yasha Mudgal reviews PACS computerisation, CAPEX expenditure; stresses timely execution

    November 17, 2026

    JK Migrant Deputation, Several other delegations call on Sagar

    November 17, 2026

    MLA Mankotia calls upon Union Home Minister Amit Shah in New Delhi

    November 17, 2026

    JMC Comm Inspects Wards 20, 21, 22; Reviews Devp Works, Interacts with Public

    November 17, 2026

    BJP holds meeting of All Cells, focusses grassroots strengthening, reviews organizational programmes

    November 17, 2026
  • Ladakh

    Ladakh’s Black-Necked Crane Population Rises 25%, Reaches 108 in 2026

    November 17, 2026

    Centre Likely to Hold Talks with Ladakh Leaders After Hill Council Polls, Says LAB Chairman

    November 15, 2026

    Ladakh Gets Major Water Security Boost as LG Approves 97 More Ponds Under Project Amrit Sarovar

    November 15, 2026

    Ladakh Gets Major Water Security Boost as LG Approves 97 New Ponds Under Project Amrit Sarovar

    November 15, 2026

    LG Saxena Inaugurates Ladakh Pavilion at India International Trade Fair 2026

    November 14, 2026
  • Entertainment

    ‘Ramayana’ Enters Rs 1,000 Crore Club, Becomes 11th Indian Film To Achieve Milestone

    November 13, 2026

    ‘Ramayana’ records 91.5 per cent jump on day 5, worldwide gross reaches Rs 673.90 crore

    November 10, 2026

    Havan-Yagna Marks Conclusion of Two-Day Shri Bala Devi Balhama Yatra

    October 18, 2026

    Rajinikanth’s ‘Jailer 2’ Collects ₹210.65 Crore Worldwide in Two Days

    October 17, 2026

    Pranav Abrol wins ‘Mr. Jammu’ and ‘Mr. Perfect’ titles at Mr India Super Model 2026 – Season 14

    October 6, 2026
  • Features Stories

    When Artificial Intelligence Becomes a Double-Edged Sword: Cyberattacks, Software Failures and the Growing Fragility of the Digital World

    November 17, 2026

    500 SPOs of J&K Police martyred, 34000 in service

    November 16, 2026

    When AI Writes the Code, Who Takes Responsibility When the World Goes Offline?

    November 13, 2026

    Manoj Sinha May Return to Modi Cabinet; Who Could Be the Next Lieutenant Governor of Jammu & Kashmir?

    November 12, 2026

    Beijing’s Slum Swap: China Turns Dhaka into Delhi in Baffling Propaganda Farce

    November 12, 2026
  • More
    • National
    • International
The Earth News
  • Home
  • Latest Stories
  • Inking The Truth
  • Jammu & Kashmir
  • Ladakh
  • Entertainment
  • National
  • International
Latest Stories National Top Headlines

‘Constitutional validity does not mean desirability’: Ex-CJI Khanna to ONOE Committee

Earth News NetworkBy Earth News NetworkAugust 17, 2025Updated:August 17, 2025No Comments3 Mins Read
Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest Copy Link Telegram LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

New Delhi, Aug 17: Former chief justice of India Sanjeev Khanna has told a parliamentary committee scrutinising the simultaneous election bill that the constitutional validity of a proposal in no way amounts to a pronouncement upon the desirability or necessity of its provisions.

In his written opinion to the committee, Khanna, however, said that arguments related to the dilution of the country’s federal structure may be raised about the constitutional amendment bill, as he listed the various claims made supporting and criticising the concept, sources said.

Most of the experts, who have shared their views with the committee headed by BJP MP P P Chaudhary, have rejected the charge that the proposals are unconstitutional but have flagged some issues with the current provisions of the bill.

Khanna, who is scheduled to interact with the committee on Tuesday, has joined a few other former chief justices of India in raising concerns over the extent of power given to the Election Commission in the bill.
He said the bill confers “unfettered discretion” on the EC in deciding that an assembly poll cannot be conducted along with that of the Lok Sabha, and to make a recommendation to the President on these lines, the sources said.

“This clause will be open to question as violating and offending the basic structure of the Constitution on the ground of being arbitrary and offending Article 14 of the Constitution,” he is learnt to have said.
Article 14 deals with equality before law.
Khanna added, “Postponement of elections by the Election Commission may result in indirect President’s rule, in other words, the Union government taking over the reins of the state government. This will be questionable judicially, as violating the federal structure envisaged by the Constitution.”

Commenting on various arguments related to the bill, he said the fact that simultaneous elections were held in 1951-52, 1957, 1962 and 1967, is a “coincidence”, certainly not an express or not even an implied constitutional mandate.
Khanna said there is a difference between “merit review” and “judicial review”.
When the Supreme Court or high courts uphold constitutional validity, it is a mere affirmation of the legislative power and that the amendment or the provision is not violative of the constitutional limitations, he said.

“The court decisions in no way amount to pronouncement upon the desirability or necessity of such provisions,” he added.Before Khanna, ex-CJIs D Y Chandrachud, J S Khehar, U U Lalit and Ranjan Gogoi have interacted with the committee members on various provisions of what is often referred to as “one nation one election” bill. The BJP and its allies have supported the bill, asserting that it will boost growth by cutting down on expenditure caused by the relentless poll cycle, leading to frequent deployment of security and civil officials on poll duty and the imposition of the Model Code of Conduct.The Opposition has argued that it undermines democratic principles and weakens federal structure. (Agencies)

Article 14 Constitution Constitutional amendment bill India Election Commission powers Federal structure Constitution Former CJI on elections India democracy debate Indian Constitution federalism Judicial review vs merit review Lok Sabha and Assembly elections One Nation One Election P P Chaudhary committee Parliament news India Parliamentary Committee simultaneous polls Presidential rule concerns Sanjeev Khanna opinion Simultaneous Elections Bill The Earth News
Follow on Google News Follow on Flipboard
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email Copy Link
Previous ArticleNo Place for Babar, Rizwan in Pakistan’s Squad for Asia Cup, UAE series
Next Article Will not let ‘conspiracy’ to ‘steal’ Bihar polls through SIR succeed: Rahul
Earth News Network
  • Website

Related Posts

PM Modi departs from Philippines after concluding two-day visit

November 17, 2026

Yasha Mudgal reviews PACS computerisation, CAPEX expenditure; stresses timely execution

November 17, 2026

JK Migrant Deputation, Several other delegations call on Sagar

November 17, 2026

Comments are closed.

Latest Posts

PM Modi departs from Philippines after concluding two-day visit

Yasha Mudgal reviews PACS computerisation, CAPEX expenditure; stresses timely execution

JK Migrant Deputation, Several other delegations call on Sagar

CM Suvendu warns against conspiracies against India, says govt will not tolerate violence, lawlessness

MLA Mankotia calls upon Union Home Minister Amit Shah in New Delhi

JMC Comm Inspects Wards 20, 21, 22; Reviews Devp Works, Interacts with Public

The Earth News
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
  • About
  • Contact us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Privacy Policy
© 2026 Earth news. All Rights Reserved. | Powered by Ideogram Technology Solutions [P] Ltd..

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.