JAMMU: Questions over fairness and transparency have intensified within the education sector after two institutions run by the Shri Mata Vaishno Devi Shrine Board were found following contrasting approaches to reservation rules during admissions despite the fact that both are functioning under the same administrative umbrella.
A detailed review of admission records shows that the Shri Mata Vaishno Devi College of Nursing adhered to reservation norms strictly during its intake in 2020, filling B.Sc. Nursing seats as per the quota system mandated by the Government to Board of Professional Entrance Examinations (BOPEE). However, in a puzzling shift, the institution discontinued the reservation matrix for four consecutive years—from 2021 to 2024—while selecting students for the programme.
In a notable reversal, the College reinstated reservation guidelines for the 2025 session, this time following the matrix prescribed in S.O. 176 dated 15-03-2024, read with S.O. 305 dated 21-05-2024.
What has triggered deeper concern, however, is that the Shri Mata Vaishno Devi Institute of Medical Excellence (SMVDIME), which also operates under the Shrine Board, did not apply the same reservation matrix while filling its first-ever batch of 50 MBBS seats through BOPEE this year.
Despite both institutions being governed by the same entity, the medical college’s decision to bypass the reservation framework has raised flags over uniformity and administrative accountability.
Stakeholders, including aspirants and education observers, say the selective application of reservation norms points to procedural inconsistencies that demand immediate scrutiny. They argue that if the Nursing College can apply reservation rules, the Medical College has no justification for ignoring them altogether, especially when admissions are conducted through the same entrance authority.
Concerns are mounting that the deviation may have deprived deserving candidates from reserved categories of rightful opportunities during MBBS admissions. Observers warn that such disparities damage public trust and undermine the credibility of institutions operating under the Shrine Board.
The issue now warrants an impartial investigation to determine why different standards were applied. Authorities have been urged to establish a consistent and transparent policy across all SMVDSB-run institutions to ensure fairness and restore confidence in the admission process.
Same Entity, Different Rules: SMVD’s Nursing College applies quota; Medical College skips it
administrative accountability Jammu B.Sc Nursing quotas Jammu BOPEE admissions controversy education transparency India Jammu Jammu education news Jammu News MBBS admission dispute reservation norms violation SMVD SMVD Medical College quota issue SMVD Nursing College reservation SMVD Shrine Board institutions SO 176 2024 SO 305 2024 The Earth News
